• Welcome to the LegalBeagles Consumer and Legal Forum.
    Please Register to get the most out of the forum. Registration is free and only needs a username and email address.
    REGISTER
    Please do not post your full name, reference numbers or any identifiable details on the forum.

Small claims advice

Collapse
Loading...
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Small claims advice

    Hi, I was just looking for some advice on going to the small claims court in regards to an item I purchased that was not as described and was internally damaged. I will try to keep it as short as possible but will explain what happened first then put my questions at the end.

    On 29/12/16 I went over to Dartford to collect a mobility scooter that was advertised as having brand new batteries and fully working. I pay a man with van £60 to take me and bring it back to where I live. We get there around midday and the guy selling it informs me he trades mobility scooters which wasn't in the advert but I wasn't bothered as at least I would have more rights if it went wrong. We go to a small back garden which is completely flat and he lets me test it. I have a drive and all seems OK and I ask again about the batteries and he confirms they are brand new. I inform him that the scooter is for me as I was on chemotherapy for colon cancer at the time and wanted something modern looking to drive around on while on chemo as I am only 35 (no offence intended to anyone older than me!).

    I decide to buy it as I thought he was unlikely to lie given that he was a mobility trader and I had already saved a copy of his advert before I set off in case there was a problem. We then spend 5 minutes squeezing it around the side of the house and to the back of the van where the man with van is stood waiting. The trader then goes to lift the back to put it on the van and I said it is OK the van man has ramps to which the trader looked a bit flustered which I didn't think much of at the time. When the ramps were put in place I told the trader it is ok the scooter will just drive itself up if I walk alongside it while pressing to go forwards. As it started to get to the foot of the ramp the trader runs up behind and gives it a huge shove up the ramps and I laugh and say it's ok that isn't needed but he only releases his hands when its completely on the van. I just took this as him being helpful at the time. Also I should add that the van man witnessed all of this.

    2 hours later we arrive back at mine and me and the van man unload the scooter. I pay him £60 and he grins as he watches me zip around on the flat road outside. I then thank him and go to go up my sloped drive as he was about to get in his van to leave. As soon as the scooter hits the slight slope it stops. I turn it off then on and have another go and get the same result. The van man witnesses this and we spend a couple of minutes wondering what is wrong and trying a few times more to drive up the slope which all fail. I ask the van man if he is willing to be a witness and he agrees. I then open the battery compartment to see if the batteries had a date on them and they did. The date was from 2012!

    I push the scooter up the slope (while on chemo so felt quite unwell after) and got inside my house and headed straight for the PC. I typed him an email describing the fault with going up slopes (it cannot even get up dropped kerbs) and also asked why it was advertised with brand new batteries when they were over 4 years old. He replies within minutes basically saying it isn't his problem as I tested the scooter in his back garden (which is flat) and that it drove up the steep ramp into the van by itself which is a lie as he pushed it. He also said the batteries may be 4 years old but he had never opened them until he installed them onto the scooter a couple of weeks ago so therefore they are still brand new. I protest and ask for a refund but he basically says tough. I then say I will get an opinion from a mobility scooter engineer to which he doesn't reply.

    We then go through the motions. I write a letter of complaint to which he responds with a letter headed "without prejudice" where he offers £100 as a goodwill gesture and repeats that the batteries are new and adds that I or the engineer must have tampered with the scooter to damage it. I inform him that even Superman wouldn't have had time to tamper with it after the time it takes to make the 2 hour journey and that I made my complaint 2 hours and ten minutes after we left his. Also the engineer I booked was not due to come and look until a few days later after I received his reply letter. The engineer turns up on the 5/1/17 and informs me the batteries are knackered and that the motor needs replacing. I do not take up his offer of £100 as I paid £650 without van man fees and a new motor is £750 and new batteries alone are £200. I then write a letter before action stating that I would like to exercise my short term right to reject the scooter as it wasn't as described and is damaged but he ignores it.

    I then start a claim through money claim online and he replies with a part admission on the batteries and offers £100 again which wouldn't even buy new ones that he advertised it with. He also states that he has been unemployed for 2 years and that he only has a few pence in the bank and that his parents would pay the £100. I am shocked at this as he told me at the time of sale that he had been trading scooters for a couple of years so he was definitely working for himself whether registered or not. I then go and find about 30 adverts of his spanning the past year selling all kinds of different mobility scooters and showing the same back garden I purchased from in the photos each time.

    That is where I am at at this point. I am nervous because I have never been to the small claims court before and am also still recovering from the chemo which a finished a few weeks ago so easing my mind a bit by asking for advice on here hopefully will relieve some of the stress.

    My questions are as follows:

    1. Does he have a leg to stand on seeing as the batteries were over 4 years old? Surely they cannot be "brand new" even left unused for 4 years in a box? As far as I am aware mobility scooter batteries usually need replacing after 2 years and go bad quickly if left uncharged.

    2. I am guessing that I cannot use his only response to me which was headed without prejudice in court? Or even mention it? If the judge asks did the trader respond am I meant to say no?

    3. The mobility scooter engineer who came out to look at it is willing to write a statement confirming the scooter was broken and the batteries were bad. Am I allowed to use that or is it considered to be an expert opinion?

    4. Does his part admission in regards to the batteries being bad hand me the win as by admitting it the scooter was obviously not as described?

    5. Does it change anything if he was unemployed but trading? He told me he was a trader. I suppose even if it were to be considered a private sale the scooter still has to match the advert as having brand new batteries which it didn't and he has made a part admission to. Oh and just to add since about a month ago he is now miraculously working as a mobility scooter engineer for some business so not like he can claim he was just any old Tom Dick or Harry that was selling his mum's prized collection of 30 mobility scooters.

    6. He is still selling them but has changed his name on the selling site but is still using the same number which when you search his number in Facebook it shows his profile and face. I have screenshots of all of this. All the photos of the new ads show the same back garden too. I have print outs the size of the Bible showing all of this. Can he just claim it isn't him but the name selling them and get away with it?

    7. Even if we exclude the batteries seeing as the fault happened within 2 hours and 10 minutes of purchase shouldn't it be down to the trader to prove the fault wasn't there at the point of sale and will it look good on him refusing my short term right to reject it which I did exercise?

    Basically do you think I have a strong case? Is it worth going all the way to court?

    I really do not want him to get away with what he did as doing that to someone on chemo who needed the scooter to get around is the lowest of the low. Also I imagine I am not the only person he has treated this way going by how dishonest he has been all the way through the process.

    Thank you for any help you can offer and I apologise for waffling on and if I didn't set the post out correctly. I am new to all of this and just typing all of this up has been quite stressful and exhausting.
    Tags: None

  • #2
    Re: Small claims advice

    I decided to go ahead with it and am preparing the evidence I will be using in court.

    Just a few quick questions:

    1. Is the written report on what is wrong with the scooter which was provided by the mobility scooter engineer I called out classed as an expert opinion?

    2. Do the witness statements have to be sent to the defendant along with the evidence at least 14 days before the trial date?

    3. Is it possible to upload videos of the faulty scooter online and play them in court? Am I allowed to do this with an online file host and play it to the judge on my mobile? The reason I ask is I took some videos of it not working properly the day after I found the fault. If this is possible how should I notify the defendant and judge that I wish to do this?

    4. He is trading under 2 different names of which one is his real name. I can prove they are both him. Do I just send the documents with the info on without saying how I can prove it on the day or do I have to include how I am going to prove there is a link before the trail? I ask as I would hate to give him a lot of time to think up yet another lie.

    5. Am I to completely exclude the without prejudice letter he sent me offering £100 as a goodwill gesture? This is the only time he has ever replied to me.

    Thank you for any help you can offer.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Small claims advice

      tagging [MENTION=6]Amethyst[/MENTION] [MENTION=39710]des8[/MENTION] [MENTION=87380]Diana M[/MENTION]
      Debt is like any other trap, easy enough to get into, but hard enough to get out of.

      It doesn't matter where your journey begins, so long as you begin it...

      recte agens confido

      ~~~~~

      Any advice I provide is given without liability, if you are unsure please seek professional legal guidance.

      I can be emailed if you need my help loading pictures/documents to your thread. My email address is Kati@legalbeagles.info
      But please include a link to your thread so I know who you are.

      Specialist advice can be sought via our sister site JustBeagle

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Small claims advice

        Hi and welcome.

        First question; How far down the process are you? You say you have already initiated court process.have yo Notice of allocation and directions?
        Second question: how did you name him on the claim form? Mr A Scammer t/a Dodgy Mobility Scooters?

        The engineer is not an "expert" witness, and his report is solely supporting evidence for your claim

        No need to refer to his "without prejudice ". letter as he has partially admitted the claim, and there is (it seems) nothing in that letter which furthers your case.

        Regarding the use of a video recording as evidence CPR states:
        If either party intends to show a video as evidence he must –
        (a) contact the court at once to make arrangements for him to do so, because the court may not have the necessary equipment, and
        (b) provide the other party with a copy of the video or the opportunity to see it at least days before the hearing.


        You state he is already claiming penury .... you might have trouble obtaining any award the judge makes in your favour.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Small claims advice

          Thank you for your reply.

          I have the notice of allocation. The trial is next month. I originally posted as I had yet to make the trial payment but decided to go ahead. He is named on the claim form as his full name.

          OK so the engineer report is OK to be included. That is great. The engineer was disgusted at how I had been treated and is willing to write a witness statement but is he allowed to? All he witnessed was the faulty scooter and not the actual purchase tat took place.

          OK I will not include the without prejudice letter. I was just wondering what to say if I am asked did he ever reply to my letters of complaint as that without prejudice letter was the only reply I ever got from them. Do I just say he never replied?

          So a video can be played. Is playing it on my phone to the judge ok? I could then upload the video online and send the defendant a link to it before the trial. Or will it need to be played to everyone in the room on a tv screen?

          Lastly he is claiming to have no money but he has been trading scooters the entire time of which I have over a years worth of evidence. He is still selling them as I type this. I also have proof he is now working as a mobility scooter engineer for a local shop.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Small claims advice

            Originally posted by Dean82 View Post
            Thank you for your reply.

            I have the notice of allocation. The trial is next month. I originally posted as I had yet to make the trial payment but decided to go ahead. He is named on the claim form as his full name.

            OK so the engineer report is OK to be included. That is great. The engineer was disgusted at how I had been treated and is willing to write a witness statement but is he allowed to? All he witnessed was the faulty scooter and not the actual purchase tat took place. I would just use his report as it stands. A witness statement from him will add nothing, and his presence might then be required so he could be questioned

            OK I will not include the without prejudice letter. I was just wondering what to say if I am asked did he ever reply to my letters of complaint as that without prejudice letter was the only reply I ever got from them. Do I just say he never replied? If you are asked you say you received a "without prejudice"letter containing an offer

            So a video can be played. Is playing it on my phone to the judge ok?No, it is too small!
            I could then upload the video online and send the defendant a link to it before the trial. Or will it need to be played to everyone in the room on a tv screen? on a monitor probably

            Lastly he is claiming to have no money but he has been trading scooters the entire time of which I have over a years worth of evidence. He is still selling them as I type this. I also have proof he is now working as a mobility scooter engineer for a local shop.
            ++So have to see what he says when you try to enforce judgement. Take your proof to court with you

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Small claims advice

              Thank you so much for your help

              Comment

              View our Terms and Conditions

              LegalBeagles Group uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience and to create a secure and effective website. By using this website, you are consenting to such use.To find out more and learn how to manage cookies please read our Cookie and Privacy Policy.

              If you would like to opt in, or out, of receiving news and marketing from LegalBeagles Group Ltd you can amend your settings at any time here.


              If you would like to cancel your registration please Contact Us. We will delete your user details on request, however, any previously posted user content will remain on the site with your username removed and 'Guest' inserted.
              Working...
              X