• Welcome to the LegalBeagles Consumer and Legal Forum.
    Please Register to get the most out of the forum. Registration is free and only needs a username and email address.
    REGISTER
    Please do not post your full name, reference numbers or any identifiable details on the forum.

Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

Collapse
Loading...
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

    Originally posted by bizzybob View Post
    There comes a problem if the Op's case came under the new rules from April 6th as if the cab was worth more than £1350, and not on finance looks like they could now lawfully have it away and flog it as it's value is greater than the £1350 allowed for tools, Nasty.

    We need to be mindful of that little "gem" as it stands, but Sweenyblue should be OK as the seizure of his vehicle was patently unlawful under the rules as they were at the time.
    I doubt that any vehicle seized by bailiffs during one of these roadside operations has been lawfully seized, irrespective of whichever set of rules were in force at the time.

    Strictly speaking, if a bailiff is acting in contravention of the conditions attached to a warrant or other order and seizes or attempts to seize a vehicle or other goods whilst acting in contravention of the conditions attached to a warrant or other order and the debtor or third party knows this, the debtor or third party may use as much reasonable force as is necessary to protect their vehicle, chattels or goods. Pushing a bailiff away would be reasonable force. In the scenario Baldrick describes, a bailiff reaching in through a car window is asking to have the window raised thereby trapping their arm or the back of their hand scratched with long fingernails. If a dog is in the car and just happens to do what comes naturally and sinks its teeth into the bailiff's hand, then my view is that it is the bailiff's own fault for crossing the line. A police officer would, in my view, be very foolish indeed and, potentially, be putting their job on the line, if they arrested the driver. I doubt very much that a stipendiary magistrate (District Judge) would take a favourable view of such action by police on hearing the bailiff was acting outside the law and the debtor or third party was, simply, defending their possessions as is their right to do so.
    Life is a journey on which we all travel, sometimes together, but never alone.

    Comment


    • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

      Originally posted by bluebottle View Post
      I doubt that any vehicle seized by bailiffs during one of these roadside operations has been lawfully seized, irrespective of whichever set of rules were in force at the time.

      Strictly speaking, if a bailiff is acting in contravention of the conditions attached to a warrant or other order and seizes or attempts to seize a vehicle or other goods whilst acting in contravention of the conditions attached to a warrant or other order and the debtor or third party knows this, the debtor or third party may use as much reasonable force as is necessary to protect their vehicle, chattels or goods. Pushing a bailiff away would be reasonable force. In the scenario Baldrick describes, a bailiff reaching in through a car window is asking to have the window raised thereby trapping their arm or the back of their hand scratched with long fingernails. If a dog is in the car and just happens to do what comes naturally and sinks its teeth into the bailiff's hand, then my view is that it is the bailiff's own fault for crossing the line. A police officer would, in my view, be very foolish indeed and, potentially, be putting their job on the line, if they arrested the driver. I doubt very much that a stipendiary magistrate (District Judge) would take a favourable view of such action by police on hearing the bailiff was acting outside the law and the debtor or third party was, simply, defending their possessions as is their right to do so.
      Yes I agree with you on the circumstances as you describe but we need clarity regarding the situation post April 6th, as it would appear any vehicle worth more than £1350, not on HP or lease is fair game, so the butcher, baker, candlestick maker and Uncle Tom Cobley and all will be signing on for JSA when the EA has their motor away as it is worth more than £1350, so is above the value MOJ has allowed for tools that are not to be taken. All in all a nasty feck up

      Comment


      • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

        Originally posted by Sweeneyblue View Post
        Would it be a criminal offence for bailiff to snatch keys from cars ignition after you have refused to speak to them.
        is there any case law?
        Only if there is someone in the car.

        If the car is unlocked, with the keys in the ignition and it is not "in use" the action is totally legal.
        The Black rat (Rattus rattus) is a common (hence the accusation of being Pleb) long-tailed rodent of the genus Rattus (rats) in the subfamily Murinae (murine rodents). The species originated in tropical Asia and spread through the Near East in Roman times (another thing that we ought to thanks the Romans for, besides roads, aqueducts and public toilets) before reaching Europe by the 1st century and spreading with Europeans across the world.

        A mutation of the beast now comes black leather clad, riding a motorcycle that looks like a battenbergh cake on wheels.

        A skilled predator, totally ruthless with it's prey, but also known to be extremely generous in doling out tickes that can provide points for motorists who want to downsize from mechanically propelled vehicles to bycicles.



        It's a dirty job, but someone got to do it!

        My opinions are free to anyone who wishes to make them theirs, but please be advised that my opinions might change without warning once more true facts are ascertained

        Comment


        • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

          Originally posted by bizzybob View Post
          There comes a problem if the Op's case came under the new rules from April 6th as if the cab was worth more than £1350, and not on finance looks like they could now lawfully have it away and flog it as it's value is greater than the £1350 allowed for tools, Nasty.

          We need to be mindful of that little "gem" as it stands, but Sweenyblue should be OK as the seizure of his vehicle was patently unlawful under the rules as they were at the time.
          My interpretation of the legislation is that the first £1,350 of one's tools are exempt from seizure, replacing the old £250 value.
          The Black rat (Rattus rattus) is a common (hence the accusation of being Pleb) long-tailed rodent of the genus Rattus (rats) in the subfamily Murinae (murine rodents). The species originated in tropical Asia and spread through the Near East in Roman times (another thing that we ought to thanks the Romans for, besides roads, aqueducts and public toilets) before reaching Europe by the 1st century and spreading with Europeans across the world.

          A mutation of the beast now comes black leather clad, riding a motorcycle that looks like a battenbergh cake on wheels.

          A skilled predator, totally ruthless with it's prey, but also known to be extremely generous in doling out tickes that can provide points for motorists who want to downsize from mechanically propelled vehicles to bycicles.



          It's a dirty job, but someone got to do it!

          My opinions are free to anyone who wishes to make them theirs, but please be advised that my opinions might change without warning once more true facts are ascertained

          Comment


          • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

            Originally posted by Sir Vere Brayne d'Emmidge View Post
            My interpretation of the legislation is that the first £1,350 of one's tools are exempt from seizure, replacing the old £250 value.
            Fair comment Sir Vere,
            therefore the vehicle could well be fair game, and the roofer would need to either get another vehicle, or try to carry ladders and tools strapped to a bicycle or go by bus.

            Would it be reasonable to expect a roofer, builder, electrician or plumber who have heavy spares and tools to use public transport to get to a site?

            On the other hand, if the van and most of the tools are seized due to the £1350, which is better than the old £250, they may well find themselves attempting to claim JSA soon after any seizure of their specialist tools

            Comment


            • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

              Originally posted by bizzybob View Post
              Yes I agree with you on the circumstances as you describe but we need clarity regarding the situation post April 6th, as it would appear any vehicle worth more than £1350, not on HP or lease is fair game, so the butcher, baker, candlestick maker and Uncle Tom Cobley and all will be signing on for JSA when the EA has their motor away as it is worth more than £1350, so is above the value MOJ has allowed for tools that are not to be taken. All in all a nasty feck up
              If the bailiff is acting in contravention of the conditions applicable to a warrant or other order, what you say pales into insignificance because the bailiff has acted outside the law.
              Life is a journey on which we all travel, sometimes together, but never alone.

              Comment


              • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

                Originally posted by bizzybob View Post
                Fair comment Sir Vere,
                therefore the vehicle could well be fair game, and the roofer would need to either get another vehicle, or try to carry ladders and tools strapped to a bicycle or go by bus.

                Would it be reasonable to expect a roofer, builder, electrician or plumber who have heavy spares and tools to use public transport to get to a site?

                On the other hand, if the van and most of the tools are seized due to the £1350, which is better than the old £250, they may well find themselves attempting to claim JSA soon after any seizure of their specialist tools
                I have a feeling that once the police learn that these roadside operations by bailiffs are unlawful, if not, illegal, and they have had their position compromised, as well as police forces being exposed to litigation and individual officers being exposed to disciplinary action which could result in dismissal from the police service, they are likely to turn on the civil enforcement industry in a way I suspect the civil enforcement industry will be neither expecting, or be prepared for, or like. The civil enforcement industry has survived and prospered by use of deceit, intimidation and compromising others' positions. You only get away with such behaviour for so long and then it comes on you with a vengeance.
                Life is a journey on which we all travel, sometimes together, but never alone.

                Comment


                • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

                  Problem is BB that if the EA has folllowed the rules the £1350 for tools max exemption may well lead to an increase in claims for IDS's disappearing benefits, like JSA from out of business and out of work plumbers electricians, builders etc.

                  Comment


                  • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

                    If the bailiff follows the law to the letter and does it outside the debtor's house or business address, if a business, and complies with the warrant/order conditions, then yes. However, I would be asking some pretty serious questions about the logic and lawfulness of a bailiff's actions, if they seized goods, knowing that doing so would mean the alleged debtor would be unable to satisfy the debt and fees, even after seizure of goods. Yes, BB, MoJ has well and truly fecked-up. However, there is nothing to prevent the courts striking-down the regulations and really fecking things up for the civil enforcement industry.
                    Life is a journey on which we all travel, sometimes together, but never alone.

                    Comment


                    • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

                      Originally posted by bluebottle View Post
                      If the bailiff follows the law to the letter and does it outside the debtor's house or business address, if a business, and complies with the warrant/order conditions, then yes. However, I would be asking some pretty serious questions about the logic and lawfulness of a bailiff's actions, if they seized goods, knowing that doing so would mean the alleged debtor would be unable to satisfy the debt and fees, even after seizure of goods. Yes, BB, MoJ has well and truly fecked-up. However, there is nothing to prevent the courts striking-down the regulations and really fecking things up for the civil enforcement industry.
                      Does the Civil Enforcement Industry think they are at the last hope hotel, and are cruising between Jack and excrement and Jack has left town. I don't think so, they think they have now the licence to carry on regardless. Hopefully they will be wrong.

                      Comment


                      • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

                        The main weapon in the Enforcement industries arsenal is IGNORANCE to many people who get involved with Bailiffs rightly or wrongly do not know the Laws and Rules they must operate under this gets them in the situations which we read of

                        Comment


                        • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

                          Originally posted by bizzybob View Post
                          Does the Civil Enforcement Industry think they are at the last hope hotel, and are cruising between Jack and excrement and Jack has left town. I don't think so, they think they have now the licence to carry on regardless. Hopefully they will be wrong.
                          My suspicion is that the civil enforcement industry believes it has been given the green light to ramp up the bullying, cheating and intimidation with Parliament's blessing. Sooner rather than later a bailiff or civil enforcement company is going to feck up so seriously, not even the most disingenuous and corrupt senior civil servants and their political masters will be able to brush it under the carpet. The regulations are the elephant in the room, along with the bloody great lump in the carpet where successive administrations have attempted to hide serious wrongdoing and feck ups from the electorate. Not any more. People are much better informed that ever before.
                          Life is a journey on which we all travel, sometimes together, but never alone.

                          Comment


                          • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

                            Originally posted by wales01man View Post
                            The main weapon in the Enforcement industries arsenal is IGNORANCE to many people who get involved with Bailiffs rightly or wrongly do not know the Laws and Rules they must operate under this gets them in the situations which we read of
                            You are correct, Wales. However, people are much better informed than they have been previously. My feeling is that a bailiff or the civil enforcement industry will feck-up so badly, it will be a case that it cannot be ignored. The fact that Lord Tugendhat told Jamie Waller he could not have an injunction to stop a Panorama programme going out that showed a JBW bailiff behaving in the most appalling manner says an awful lot.
                            Life is a journey on which we all travel, sometimes together, but never alone.

                            Comment


                            • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

                              So Parking Mad could well be the beginning of the end for the Enforcement industry. If that JBW bailiffs behaviour was par for the course JBW are in for a rocky ride, if he behaved like that where I live, he wouldn't have got out of the estate in one piece.

                              Comment


                              • Re: Stop by police during routine check baliff took my pco reg.taxi

                                My feelings about Parking Mad, BB, is that the programme-makers and the BBC would be wise to make it clear to viewers that the roadside operations by Whyte and Co are of questionable legality. Allowing the programme-makers and BBC the benefit of doubt, something along the lines of -

                                "The BBC and the makers of Parking Mad have been made aware that the actions of certificated bailiffs taking part in roadside operations with police officers, as featured in the programme, may not have been lawful at the time the programme was made or since it was broadcast. The BBC and the programme-makers wish to make it clear that they were not aware of this at the time of commissioning or during the making of the programme and received the information referred to following the programme being broadcast."

                                should be enough to be fair to the BBC and the programme-maker, but enough to have motorists who were "robbed" getting sufficiently worked-up to take action against Whyte & Co and the local authorities who employed them, as well as the Metropolitan Police.
                                Life is a journey on which we all travel, sometimes together, but never alone.

                                Comment

                                View our Terms and Conditions

                                LegalBeagles Group uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience and to create a secure and effective website. By using this website, you are consenting to such use.To find out more and learn how to manage cookies please read our Cookie and Privacy Policy.

                                If you would like to opt in, or out, of receiving news and marketing from LegalBeagles Group Ltd you can amend your settings at any time here.


                                If you would like to cancel your registration please Contact Us. We will delete your user details on request, however, any previously posted user content will remain on the site with your username removed and 'Guest' inserted.
                                Working...
                                X