• Welcome to the LegalBeagles Consumer and Legal Forum.
    Please Register to get the most out of the forum. Registration is free and only needs a username and email address.
    REGISTER
    Please do not post your full name, reference numbers or any identifiable details on the forum.

Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

Collapse
Loading...
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

    Hello,
    I understand that so-called 'baby hatches' don't exist in the U.K. because they're against the law. However, in several EU countries the practice exists. E.g. in Germany several 'baby hatches' exist legally as I understand that there is a loophole in the law that allows for this practice. My question is as follows: If a pregnant English national travels to Germany, gives birth there to a child and subsequently abandons the child in a baby hatch, can she be prosecuted in the U.K. (although what she did was legal in Germany)?
    Many thanks,
    C.P.

  • #2
    Re: Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

    Well if she can't, she bloody well should be.
    And anyone who condones or encourages this malpractice, should also be prosecuted.
    Just what do people think babies are?
    Having a surrogate mother is one thing, but to abandon the baby to God knows who, is morally wrong.
    If we haven't got a law here that protects the baby, then we should get one ASAP.
    “The only man who sticks closer to you in adversity more than a friend, is a creditor.”

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

      Thank you for your response, but I'm not so much interested in the moral implications of it as in the legal ones. Could anybody advice what the implications would be within U.K. law?

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

        I'm sorry I can't answer your query.

        BUT Jb (and you knew it would be me :tinysmile_twink_t2 there are other opinions.
        http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/h...vival.16826856

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

          Originally posted by Carl Philip View Post
          Hello,
          I understand that so-called 'baby hatches' don't exist in the U.K. because they're against the law. However, in several EU countries the practice exists. E.g. in Germany several 'baby hatches' exist legally as I understand that there is a loophole in the law that allows for this practice. My question is as follows: If a pregnant English national travels to Germany, gives birth there to a child and subsequently abandons the child in a baby hatch, can she be prosecuted in the U.K. (although what she did was legal in Germany)?
          Many thanks,
          C.P.
          Hi,
          Could I ask you if this concerns you as a potential father, or maybe you are looking to adopt a child in Germany?
          It's just a strange question for a man to ask.
          You can always send me a private message if it is too personal for the forum
          “The only man who sticks closer to you in adversity more than a friend, is a creditor.”

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

            Originally posted by des8 View Post
            I'm sorry I can't answer your query.

            BUT Jb (and you knew it would be me :tinysmile_twink_t2 there are other opinions.
            http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/h...vival.16826856
            Knew you would have a say on this very delicate subject, Des mate.
            It appears that between 50 and 60 babies are abandoned in the UK each year.
            As I said Des, I have nothing against surrogacy, or even fostering, but to abandon a child........ Come on mate
            “The only man who sticks closer to you in adversity more than a friend, is a creditor.”

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

              In the United Kingdom there are no baby hatches, as they are illegal: under section 27 of the Offences against the Person Act 1861 the law states that any mother who abandons a child less than two years of age is a criminal and can face up to five years' imprisonment.
              In practice, such prosecutions are extremely rare and would only occur if the circumstances of child abandonment showed actual malice, i.e. appeared deliberately intended to result in the death of the child. A mother who wishes to have her newborn baby adopted can do so. Counselling is designed to ensure that giving up the baby is her genuine, irrevocable wish.

              In Germany, the baby hatch system only just borders on the legal; normally a mother who abandons her child is committing a criminal act. However, according to the German social laws, parents are allowed to leave their child in the charge of a third party for up to eight weeks, for example if the parents need to go into hospital. After eight weeks, however, the youth welfare office must be called in.
              German law considers babies left in the baby hatch as if they have been left in the charge of a third party. This loophole is extremely controversial as there have been some cases in Germany where the baby hatches have been used to abandon disabled children or babies already three months old. Several attempts have been made to clear up the legal basis for baby hatches and how to treat the children left in them, but as yet the situation is still not clearly regulated.


              In the Czech Republic, the Ministry of Social Affairs confirmed in 2006 that baby hatches are legal under Czech law. In contradiction to this, in March 2006, Colonel Anna Piskova, a police officer, said on Czech television that the police would look for the mothers of abandoned children. The head of the Czech baby hatch organization Statim, Ludvik Hess, complained about this statement and was officially supported by the Save the Children Foundation. As of September 2013, there are 57 baby hatches in the country, mostly in major cities. So far, they have helped to save 92 children.

              In Austria, the law treats babies found in baby hatches as foundlings. The local social services office for children and young people (Jugendwohlfahrt) takes care of the child for the first six months and then it is given up for adoption. Women have had the right to give birth anonymously since 2001.

              The United Nations has questioned the legality of baby boxes, criticizing the high number of children's group homes and claiming the boxes violate children's rights.
              Debt is like any other trap, easy enough to get into, but hard enough to get out of.

              It doesn't matter where your journey begins, so long as you begin it...

              recte agens confido

              ~~~~~

              Any advice I provide is given without liability, if you are unsure please seek professional legal guidance.

              I can be emailed if you need my help loading pictures/documents to your thread. My email address is Kati@legalbeagles.info
              But please include a link to your thread so I know who you are.

              Specialist advice can be sought via our sister site JustBeagle

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

                In serious cases, such as travelling abroad to commit sexual offences etc this is punishable in the UK courts.

                My gut feeling is that an offence such as this would not progress in the British legal criminal system as there would probably be low interest from the UK police.

                I doubt this particular circumstance has ever occurred before so I suspect there is not going to be a definitive answer to your question, there are so many conflicting issues such as the mothers psychological welfare, the childs' welfare and future that I can't see how any criminal action would assist in resolution.

                If you look at the many cases of child abandonment, or even infanticide of a newborn, it is rare to see criminal proceedings as the mother is often classified as in need of help rather than punishment.
                "Although scalar fields are Lorentz scalars, they may transform nontrivially under other symmetries, such as flavour or isospin. For example, the pion is invariant under the restricted Lorentz group, but is an isospin triplet (meaning it transforms like a three component vector under the SU(2) isospin symmetry). Furthermore, it picks up a negative phase under parity inversion, so it transforms nontrivially under the full Lorentz group; such particles are called pseudoscalar rather than scalar. Most mesons are pseudoscalar particles." (finally explained to a captivated Celestine by Professor Brian Cox on Wednesday 27th June 2012 )

                I am proud to have co-founded LegalBeagles in 2007

                If we have helped you we'd appreciate it if you can leave a review on our Trust Pilot page

                If you wish to book an appointment with me to discuss your credit agreement, please email kate@legalbeaglesgroup. com

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

                  Originally posted by Johnboy007 View Post
                  I have nothing against surrogacy, or even fostering, but to abandon a child........ Come on mate
                  My feelings on this exactly Jb ... I know it does happen, but I cannot understand HOW a mother can abandon the child she has carried for 9 months
                  Debt is like any other trap, easy enough to get into, but hard enough to get out of.

                  It doesn't matter where your journey begins, so long as you begin it...

                  recte agens confido

                  ~~~~~

                  Any advice I provide is given without liability, if you are unsure please seek professional legal guidance.

                  I can be emailed if you need my help loading pictures/documents to your thread. My email address is Kati@legalbeagles.info
                  But please include a link to your thread so I know who you are.

                  Specialist advice can be sought via our sister site JustBeagle

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

                    Originally posted by des8 View Post
                    I'm sorry I can't answer your query.

                    BUT Jb (and you knew it would be me :tinysmile_twink_t2 there are other opinions.
                    http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/h...vival.16826856
                    Knew you would have a say on this very delicate subject, Des mate.
                    It appears that between 50 and 60 babies are abandoned in the UK each year.
                    In Germany, babies are first looked after for eight weeks during which the mother can return and claim her child without any legal repercussions. If this does not happen, after eight weeks the child is put up for adoption.
                    I managed to find this out, which may give Carl some sort of answer.
                    In the United Kingdom there are no baby hatches, as they are illegal: under section 27 of the Offences against the Person Act 1861 the law states that any mother who abandons a child less than two years of age is a criminal and can face up to five years' imprisonment. In practice, such prosecutions are extremely rare and would only occur if the circumstances of child abandonment showed actual malice, i.e. appeared deliberately intended to result in the death of the child. A mother who wishes to have her newborn baby adopted can do so. Counseling is designed to ensure that giving up the baby is her genuine, irrevocable wish.

                    “The only man who sticks closer to you in adversity more than a friend, is a creditor.”

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

                      Hi JB,

                      I had thought about providing some more background as to why I'm asking this question but was a little anxious I wouldn't be taken seriously. But since you explicitly ask: I'm a writer of fiction and one of my characters is in the position as described earlier. Ideally, she would be prosecuted by UK law (in order for the plot to work) so I'm hoping for a response from someone that confirms this.
                      As for the moral implications of all this: I agree with you that abandoning a baby is morally wrong. But who are we, especially as males, to judge a woman who is so desperate she sees no other solution. As the article posted by Des points out, there are enough situations that would drive even the strongest souls among us to utter despair.
                      Cheers,
                      C.P.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

                        Desperation, lack of support, pressure, fear, hope .......... all manner of reasons. The woman may have been the victim of abuse, rape, prostitution. It happens, in secret, and better in safety.
                        #staysafestayhome

                        Any support I provide is offered without liability, if you are unsure please seek professional legal guidance.

                        Received a Court Claim? Read >>>>> First Steps

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

                          Originally posted by Carl Philip View Post
                          Hi JB,

                          I had thought about providing some more background as to why I'm asking this question but was a little anxious I wouldn't be taken seriously. But since you explicitly ask: I'm a writer of fiction and one of my characters is in the position as described earlier. Ideally, she would be prosecuted by UK law (in order for the plot to work) so I'm hoping for a response from someone that confirms this.
                          As for the moral implications of all this: I agree with you that abandoning a baby is morally wrong. But who are we, especially as males, to judge a woman who is so desperate she sees no other solution. As the article posted by Des points out, there are enough situations that would drive even the strongest souls among us to utter despair.
                          Cheers,
                          C.P.
                          The mother could only be prosecuted if the pregnancy was known about (ie the hatch is a secret so it would never be known who dropped off the baby unless she chose to return or identify herself) so the plot falls down I think, unless you add a confidant in The father would have rights too if he is known/aware.

                          I think possibly think about things like Dignitas and how people who assist with airfairs/travel arrangements can be prosecuted for helping UK nationals to attend.
                          #staysafestayhome

                          Any support I provide is offered without liability, if you are unsure please seek professional legal guidance.

                          Received a Court Claim? Read >>>>> First Steps

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

                            Hi again JB,
                            Thanks for the info and the effort! I had come across similar information but in my scenario the question is whether she is breaking U.K. law if her action happens abroad (e.g. in Germany).
                            Thanks again,
                            C.P.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Abandoning a newborn in a 'baby hatch' as a foundling

                              It would seem that it is only in cases of murder and manslaughter that uk courts have extra territorial jurisdiction over criminal acts committed abroad by UK citizens

                              Comment

                              View our Terms and Conditions

                              LegalBeagles Group uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience and to create a secure and effective website. By using this website, you are consenting to such use.To find out more and learn how to manage cookies please read our Cookie and Privacy Policy.

                              If you would like to opt in, or out, of receiving news and marketing from LegalBeagles Group Ltd you can amend your settings at any time here.


                              If you would like to cancel your registration please Contact Us. We will delete your user details on request, however, any previously posted user content will remain on the site with your username removed and 'Guest' inserted.
                              Working...
                              X